| 
Points for Physical Book | 
Points for Kindle or Kindle app | 
| 
DEPENDABLE – my paperback is not going to run out of charge
  or mysteriously delete a file. | 
COST – Despite their
  wacky price structure, ebooks are almost always cheaper, as you can avoid all
  the physical costs like ink, paper and shipping.  | 
| 
UBIQUITOUS – I can read a physical book in school during a
  free class, whereas, because ebooks are less common, I can’t use a Kindle app
  on my iPad or iPod to read. Everyone knows what a book is.  | 
HANDY – I carried
  four reading-for-pleasure books around in my bag today. That could become a
  lot lighter if they were all just stored on one item. Good for students with
  heavy workloads.  | 
| 
FAMILIAR
  - this is
  especially important for the elderly, who are often technophobic. Books can
  be comforting because they hold memories. A slab of metal probably doesn’t
  hold memories for a particular book. | 
REVIEWING – I find the
  Kindle app wonderful when reviewing books, because it collects all the
  highlights and notes I left throughout the text in a separate document, which
  I can use as a rough guide for my review.  | 
| 
PEACE
  & FOCUS – Physical books
  protect you from the distractions that come with internet-equipped devices
  and let you just enjoy a good story with less disruption. | 
SUSTAINABLE – While resources
  are used making the Kindle, it’s less than what’s used to make hundreds of
  thousands of books. | 
| 
SENSORY
  EXPERIENCE – Books with
  beautiful, tactile covers and new-book smell, that you can display proudly
  and organise on your shelves by height, genre, author, colour bring a special
  joy to this world.  | 
MULTIPURPOSE – A book is just
  a book; a Kindle (most versions) can surf the web and more.  | 
| 
LEGITIMACY
  – Rightly or
  wrongly, physical books have an air of legitimacy that ebooks just don’t.
  Especially since anyone can self-publish rubbish through Amazon, it can feel
  like validation for an author when they see their work all dressed up in a
  book.  | 
TRANSITION – I mentioned
  earlier that the elderly are often technophobic. Kindles or Kindle apps, by
  combining something familiar (books, stories) with something new (technology)
  can act as a bridge.  | 
| 
EMPLOYMENT
  – Dozens of people
  (if not more) work together to create a physical book (“It takes a village”).
  From layout designers to cover designers printers to distributors to
  bookstore workers, everyone is needed. Some of these jobs stay for an ebook,
  but definitely not all.  | 
FREEDOM – I know I’ve
  linked e-books and self-publishing quite a lot here, but they are definitely
  intertwined. E-books, and by extension reading on Kindle, brings new voices
  that might not be heard through the established publishing industry. Flipside
  of Legitimacy. | 
| 
This post is in table form, which is quite
  labour-intensive but very pretty. Feel free to share around on Twitter,
  Facebook or wherever else you like. Also, if you have any more points on
  either side or wish to remark on mine, please leave a comment below.  | 
 
 
 
 
Extremely insightful and interesting post highlighting the advantages and disadvantages of a Kindle without any biased opinion. Really well done and well presented. The table looks beautiful! A result of hard work. Great job!
ReplyDeleteGood post! I am also going to write a blog post about this... thanks
ReplyDeletehealth and physical education book